Press ESC to close

Character-Based Stories vs. Plot-Based Stories: Ghost Machine’s Approach To Comic Books

In the 80s and 90s, most writers focused on character-based stories that created some of the most complex and relatable characters. However, in recent years, major publishers like Marvel and DC have altered course to focus on creating a thrilling and action-packed plot. In a recent Geek Network interview, Francis Manapul talked about how Ghost Machine aims to return to the basics.

This new comic book company, started by Geoff Johns, will focus on creator-owned content and relatable character-based stories. While they each have their merits, they impact the story differently. Here is a brief overview of the strengths and pitfalls of each approach.

Character-Based Stories:

Character-based stories typically emphasize character development and evolution. In such comic books, the narrative organically unfolds as characters grapple with internal motivations, conflicts, and growth arcs. The driving force in such comics lies in the character’s choices, personalities, and relationships. Character-based stories have various strengths over their counterparts. These include;

  • Emotional Connection: Character-based stories create deep emotional connections between the audience and the characters. Readers become invested in the characters’ journeys, rooting for their successes and empathizing with their struggles.
  • Realism: By focusing on the intricacies of human nature, character-based stories often feel more authentic and relatable. The characters’ flaws and vulnerabilities mirror the complexity of real-life individuals, making the narrative more compelling. According to Marvel and Stan Lee, this is what makes the character of Spider-Man so iconic and relatable.
  • Longevity: Well-developed characters have the potential to endure beyond a single story. Iconic characters become timeless, remaining in the hearts and minds of audiences long after.

While character-based stories have many strengths, they also come with some challenges. Here is the top disadvantage.

  • Pacing: These stories tend to be more introspective and slower-paced, so they may not appeal to readers seeking fast-paced action.

Plot-Based Stories:

In contrast, plot-based stories prioritize the events and conflicts that drive the narrative forward. The focus is on the sequence of events, twists, and turns that create tension and propel the story towards its climax and resolution. Below are the top strengths of plot-based stories. 

  • Engaging and Dynamic: Plot-based stories are often fast-paced and dynamic, keeping the audience on the edge of their seats. The constant stream of events and revelations can be exhilarating and addictive.
  • Clear Structure: The emphasis on the plot provides a clear and structured framework for the story.
  • Versatility: Plot-driven narratives can be applied to various genres, from action and thriller to mystery and science fiction. This adaptability allows for a wide range of storytelling possibilities.

The potential pitfalls of plot-based stories include:

  • Shallow Characterization: In some plot-driven stories, characters may take a backseat to the events, resulting in underdeveloped or stereotypical personas.
  • Lack of Emotional Resonance: While plot twists and turns can be thrilling, they may not elicit the same emotional depth as character-driven narratives. According to The Wildcat Tribune, writers may also be tempted to go for shock value instead of building captivating storylines.

The most impactful stories often find a delicate balance between character and plot. A compelling narrative weaves a rich tapestry where well-developed characters navigate through a thoughtfully constructed story. Writers can create a synergy that enhances both elements, allowing for emotional engagement and an exciting narrative arc.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *